Tirthak's Library

Turning on the library lights

History · 10 modules · 31 steps

The Shape of History

History taught as an argument about evidence rather than a list of dates. It opens with how historians actually work and what gets left out of the record, then moves through the human past without treating Europe as the trunk and everywhere else as branches: the first cities, the plural classical worlds, Afro-Eurasia in the middle centuries, the divergence, empire, and the twentieth century read from more than one side. Historians of the last fifty years are read as practitioners rather than as commentary. The promise is that you will meet a historical claim and know which question to ask of it.

How Historians Think→First Cities→Classical Worlds, Plural→Medieval Afro-Eurasia→The Islamic and Chinese Centuries→Renaissance and Early Globalisation→Revolutions and Industry→Empire and Nation→World Wars and Decolonisation→Cold War and After
Progress 0/31
0%

Sign in to track your progress, create a TBR list, and add notes.

Module 1

How Historians Think

Three books about the craft before any of the content. What a fact is, what the record leaves out on purpose, and how a historian decides what scale to work at.

Core · Book

What Is History?

E.H. Carr

Carr's 1961 lectures on why the facts do not speak for themselves and why you should study the historian before you study the history. Still the standard first book.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoWhat is History? E.H. CarrThen & Now

Carr's central claim about the selection of facts, explained with the objections that followed it.

Open companion
Core · Book

Silencing the Past

Michel-Rolph Trouillot

Trouillot shows how silences enter the record at four separate points, and uses the Haitian Revolution, an event Europe declared unthinkable while it was happening, to prove it.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoHaiti and the Unthinkable: Michel-Rolph Trouillot's Silencing the PastVinay Lal

A historian walking through the four moments where power enters the making of history.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Landscape of History

John Lewis Gaddis

Gaddis on how historians think: scale, abstraction, contingency, and why history is closer to cartography than to physics.

Companion · use alongside
VideoJohn Lewis Gaddis on grand strategy and historical thinkingPolitics and Prose

Gaddis himself on how he reasons about the past, which is the subject of the book.

Open companion
Module 2

First Cities

The settled world was not a single inevitable step. Three books that take the archaeology seriously and find far more variety and far more choice than the standard story allows.

Core · Book

The Dawn of Everything

David Graeber and David Wengrow

An anthropologist and an archaeologist demolish the story in which agriculture leads inevitably to hierarchy. Contested, enormous, and the most exciting history book of the last decade.

Companion · use alongside
VideoGraeber and Wengrow on the Myth of the Stupid SavageRed Plateaus

Both authors together at a conference, arguing that indigenous critics of Europe shaped the Enlightenment itself.

Open companion
Core · Book

Against the Grain

James C. Scott

Scott's argument is that the earliest states depended on grain because grain can be seen, counted and taxed, and that plenty of people sensibly ran away from them.

Companion · use alongside
VideoJames C. Scott: The Domestication of Fire, Animals, Grains and UsFaculty of Arts, Aarhus Universitet

Scott delivering the argument himself, including why he thinks barbarians had the better deal.

Open companion
Core · Book

Cities: The First 6,000 Years

Monica L. Smith

An archaeologist on what has stayed constant about urban life since the first cities: density, rubbish, strangers, specialisation and the pull that keeps drawing people in.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe World's First CityThe Rest Is History

Two historians on Uruk and what the earliest urban life actually involved.

Open companion
Module 3

Classical Worlds, Plural

Three founding historians from three traditions, writing at roughly the same civilisational moment and inventing the job independently of each other.

Core · Book

The Histories

Herodotus

The first work of history in the European tradition, and much stranger than its reputation: ethnography, tall tales, and a serious attempt to explain why Greeks and Persians fought.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoWho Is Herodotus, The Father Of History?MoAn Inc.

What Herodotus was actually trying to do, and why he was called the father of lies as well.

Open companion
Core · Book

SPQR

Mary Beard

Rome from the founding myths to the extension of citizenship in 212, written by someone unusually interested in the people who were not senators.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoMary Beard on SPQR: The History of Ancient RomeThe 92nd Street Y, New York

Beard on what she left out, what the sources will not tell us, and how Rome kept absorbing people.

Open companion
Core · Book

Records of the Grand Historian

Sima Qian

The founding work of Chinese historiography, written after its author chose castration over suicide in order to finish it. Read the Burton Watson selections.

Companion · use alongside
VideoHerodotus and Sima Qian: What's the Difference Between Western and East Asian History?Cool History Bros

The two founding historians compared, which shows how differently the job could have been invented.

Open companion
Module 4

Medieval Afro-Eurasia

The centuries when the centre of gravity was not in western Europe. Three books that put the connections first and the nation-states nowhere.

Core · Book

The Inheritance of Rome

Chris Wickham

Europe and the Mediterranean from 400 to 1000, treated as a period with its own logic rather than as a gap between Rome and the Renaissance.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Early Middle Ages: The Crucial Seventh CenturyYaleCourses

A Yale lecture on the century in which the post-Roman world settled into its new shape.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Silk Roads

Peter Frankopan

A world history written from Central Asia outwards, in which Europe is a late arrival at somebody else's trading system.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoBook at Lunchtime: The Silk Roads, A New History of the WorldTORCH, The Oxford Research Centre in the Humanities

Frankopan and other historians discussing what changes when you move the centre of the map.

Open companion
Core · Book

Destiny Disrupted

Tamim Ansary

World history narrated as it looks from inside the Islamic world, in which the Crusades are a border incident and 1492 is a defeat. Written for the general reader and very readable.

Companion · use alongside
VideoHow Islam BeganThe University of Chicago

A historian on the origins of Islam and the empire that formed around it, which is where Ansary's story starts.

Open companion
Module 5

The Islamic and Chinese Centuries

While Europe was provincial, two other places were not. Three books on the periods that most Western curriculums skip between the fall of Rome and the Renaissance.

Core · Book

The House of Wisdom

Jim Al-Khalili

A physicist on the Arabic scientific tradition: translation, algebra, optics, medicine, and the awkward fact that Europe's recovery ran through Baghdad and Cordoba.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe House of Wisdom and the legacy of Arabic ScienceThe Royal Society

Al-Khalili delivering the argument at the Royal Society, with the manuscripts.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Ornament of the World

Maria Rosa Menocal

Muslim, Jewish and Christian Spain over seven centuries, told through poets, viziers and libraries. Romantic in places, and the argument is worth having.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Jews of Al-AndalusHenry Abramson

A historian on the Jewish golden age in Muslim Spain, including the parts that complicate the harmony.

Open companion
Core · Book

China: A History

John Keay

Five thousand years in one volume by a writer who does not assume you know any of it. The best single-book route into Chinese history for an outsider.

Companion · use alongside
Video2,000 Years of Chinese History: The Mandate of Heaven and ConfuciusCrashCourse

The dynastic cycle and the mandate of heaven, which are the two ideas the whole narrative hangs on.

Open companion
Module 6

Renaissance and Early Globalisation

Europe reorganises itself and then arrives everywhere else. One classic that invented the period, one on the split that broke Christendom, and one on what actually crossed the Atlantic.

Core · Book

The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy

Jacob Burckhardt

The 1860 book that created the Renaissance as a period and as an idea about the discovery of the individual. Read it as evidence about the nineteenth century as well.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoLegacy of the Renaissance and Early Italian RenaissanceArt History with Travis Lee Clark

A lecture on the period Burckhardt named and on how much of his framing has survived.

Open companion
Core · Book

Reformation

Diarmaid MacCulloch

Europe's house divided, from 1490 to 1700, written with an ear for what people actually believed and how much of it was about anything other than doctrine.

Companion · use alongside
VideoDiarmaid MacCulloch on Thomas Cromwell, Henry VIII and the reformationDavid Coast

MacCulloch on the English end of the story, and on the difference between the politics and the faith.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Columbian Exchange

Alfred W. Crosby

The book that made historians take biology seriously: maize, potatoes, horses, smallpox. The most consequential thing about 1492 was not gold.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Columbian Exchange: Crash Course World HistoryCrashCourse

What moved in each direction and what it did to populations on both sides.

Open companion
Module 7

Revolutions and Industry

The dual revolution, the revolution that Europe refused to see, and the question of why industrialisation happened where it did rather than where it might have.

Core · Book

The Age of Revolution

Eric Hobsbawm

The French and industrial revolutions treated as one event with two faces, 1789 to 1848. The first volume of the best narrative history of the modern world.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoInterviews with Historians: Eric HobsbawmInstitute of Historical Research

Hobsbawm on his own method and on writing history as someone with declared politics.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Black Jacobins

C.L.R. James

The Haitian Revolution and Toussaint Louverture, written in 1938 by a Trinidadian Marxist who saw it as the only successful slave revolt in history and treated it as a revolution rather than a rising.

Companion · use alongside
VideoHaiti's Revolution is Insanely Interesting. Here's Why.William C. Fox

The events in order, which helps enormously before reading James on what they meant.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Great Divergence

Kenneth Pomeranz

Pomeranz compares the Yangzi delta with England around 1750 and finds them far closer than expected, which moves the explanation for industrialisation onto coal and colonies.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoBeyond the 'Great Divergence' DebateCAPI at the University of Victoria

Pomeranz himself on the comparison and on the two decades of argument it started.

Open companion
Module 8

Empire and Nation

How the nation was invented, how it was studied, and what it did where it was imposed. Four books that between them cover the machinery and the cost.

Core · Book

Imagined Communities

Benedict Anderson

Anderson's claim is that a nation is an imagined community, made possible by print, the census and the map. The most influential book on nationalism ever written.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoBenedict Anderson: 'Nationalism and Time'UCD School of Sociology

Anderson lecturing on his own argument late in his career, with the revisions he had made to it.

Open companion
Core · Book

Orientalism

Edward Said

Said on how Europe produced knowledge about the East that served the governing of it. Contested for fifty years, and you cannot follow the argument without reading it.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoEdward Said on OrientalismPalestine Diary

Said explaining the book himself, which is the clearest available statement of what he did and did not claim.

Open companion
Core · Book

King Leopold's Ghost

Adam Hochschild

The Congo Free State, run as one man's private property, and the first modern human rights campaign that exposed it. Narrative history at its most effective.

Companion · use alongside
VideoObject of Plunder: The Congo through the CenturiesGetty Research Institute

Hochschild on the Congo across the longer span, including what happened after Leopold.

Open companion
Core · Book

Late Victorian Holocausts

Mike Davis

Davis argues that the great famines of the 1870s and 1890s in India, China and Brazil were not natural disasters but the meeting of El Nino with market ideology and empire.

Companion · use alongside
VideoHow the British Looted 43 Trillion Dollars and Impoverished IndiaOdd Compass

The economics of colonial extraction in India, which is the machinery Davis says turned droughts into famines.

Open companion
Module 9

World Wars and Decolonisation

The century's two catastrophes and the movement that came out of them. Read the third book against the first two rather than after them.

Core · Book

The Guns of August

Barbara Tuchman

The first month of the First World War, reconstructed hour by hour. Tuchman's subject is how intelligent people walked into something none of them wanted.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoJuly 1914: Countdown to WarThe Kansas City Public Library

A historian on the diplomatic crisis, with the argument about who was responsible laid out.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Second World War

Antony Beevor

One volume, genuinely global, and strongest where most accounts are weakest: the Pacific, China, and the war's effect on civilians.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoAntony Beevor on 'The Second World War'C-SPAN

Beevor on what a single-volume global account has to leave out and what he refused to leave out.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Wretched of the Earth

Frantz Fanon

Written as Algeria's war was ending by a psychiatrist who had treated both torturers and the tortured. The most uncomfortable and most necessary book on decolonisation.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoFrantz Fanon's 'The Wretched of the Earth'Theory & Philosophy

A close reading of the opening argument about violence, which is the part most often quoted without context.

Open companion
Module 10

Cold War and After

Three books on the last eighty years, chosen so that the story is not told only from Washington or only from Europe.

Core · Book

The Cold War: A World History

Odd Arne Westad

Westad treats the Cold War as a global conflict fought mostly in the poor world, which is where nearly all of the dying happened.

Companion · use alongside
VideoHistory of The Cold War with Professor Arne WestadCary Memorial Library

Westad on why the conflict has to be told from the periphery rather than from the two capitals.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Jakarta Method

Vincent Bevins

The anticommunist mass killings of 1965 in Indonesia and the programme they became a model for. Journalism built on archives and on interviews with survivors.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Jakarta Method: How the CIA Promoted Mass Murder and Terrorism Against the LeftBreakThrough News

Bevins on the reporting, the archive and what he found in Indonesia.

Open companion
Core · Book

Postwar

Tony Judt

Europe from 1945 to 2005 in nine hundred pages, east and west given equal weight, by a historian who thought the continent had not finished dealing with its memory.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoTony Judt lecture on post-war EuropeBall State University Libraries

Judt lecturing on the period, which gives you his voice before the nine hundred pages.

Open companion