Tirthak's Library

Turning on the library lights

Philosophy · 12 modules · 36 steps

Western Philosophy

A guided self-education in the Western philosophical tradition, read as a single long argument rather than a gallery of great men. You start with the whole story in outline, learn what an argument is and how to take one apart, then follow the questions from Athens through the Christian, Islamic and Jewish middle ages into the modern self, Kant, the nineteenth century, existentialism and the analytic turn. The promise is not memorising philosophers; it is being able to recognise an argument, reconstruct it honestly, test it, and say why you accept or reject it.

The Shape of the Argument→How to Read an Argument→The Greeks→How to Live→Faith and Reason→The Modern Self→Kant and Wollstonecraft→The Nineteenth Century→Existence and Freedom→The Analytic Turn→After the Canon→Philosophy Now
Progress 0/36
0%

Sign in to track your progress, create a TBR list, and add notes.

Module 1

The Shape of the Argument

Before any primary text, get the whole story in outline. You will not remember all of it, and that is fine. The point is to have a map in your head so that every later reading has somewhere to sit.

Core · Book

A Little History of Philosophy

Nigel Warburton

Forty short chapters running from Socrates to Peter Singer. The best single overview in English, and deliberately written for people with no background.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Most Influential Philosophers Explained in 26 MinutesJaydone History

The entire tradition at speed. Watch it once now and again at the end of the pathway.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Problems of Philosophy

Bertrand Russell

Not a history. Russell takes a table and asks whether you can know it is there, and by the end you understand what philosophical work actually consists of.

Companion · use alongside
VideoBertrand Russell's PhilosophyAttic Philosophy

A working philosopher on what Russell was doing and why it mattered.

Open companion
Optional · excellent but not necessary
BookThe Story of PhilosophyBryan Magee

The illustrated version of the same map, if you would rather see the tradition laid out visually.

Module 2

How to Read an Argument

Philosophy is a skill before it is a subject. These two short books hand you the equipment: how to find the claim, find the reasons, and tell a good move from a bad one.

Core · Book

Think: A Compelling Introduction to Philosophy

Simon Blackburn

Blackburn walks through the central problems while showing you the moves. Read it as a demonstration of method rather than for conclusions.

Companion · use alongside
VideoBranches of philosophy: Metaphysics, epistemology and ethicsJan Willem Lindemans

Seven minutes on how the field divides up, so you know which kind of question you are looking at.

Open companion
Core · Book

A Rulebook for Arguments

Anthony Weston

Under a hundred pages, and the most useful thing on this list. Rules for constructing an argument and for spotting when someone is not making one.

Companion · use alongside
VideoIdentifying Premises and ConclusionsKevin deLaplante

A philosopher demonstrating the single most transferable skill here: separating what is being claimed from what is offered in support.

Open companion
Module 3

The Greeks

Western philosophy begins as conversation, not doctrine. Read Plato for the method before you read anyone for conclusions, and notice that Socrates almost never reaches an answer.

Core · Book

Euthyphro and Meno

Plato

Two short dialogues that show the method in miniature. A definition is offered, tested and destroyed, and the destruction is the point.

Companion · use alongside
VideoPlato's Euthyphro: Which comes first, God or Morality?Jeffrey Kaplan

Kaplan takes the dilemma apart slowly. Watch after reading and you will see what you missed.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Republic

Plato

The most ambitious book in the tradition: justice, the soul, education, art and the ideal state, all from one question about whether it pays to be good.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoPlato's Republic I: Justice, Power, KnowledgeMichael Sugrue

A famous lecture by a professor who clearly loves the text. Long, and worth every minute.

Open companion
Core · Book

Nicomachean Ethics

Aristotle

Aristotle asks what a good human life is and answers with character rather than rules. The origin of virtue ethics and still its best statement.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoAristotle's guide to the good lifeJared Henderson

A close, patient reading of what Aristotle means by virtue, which is not what the word suggests today.

Open companion
Module 4

How to Live

Philosophy as practice rather than theory. Three Roman writers who assumed the point of the subject was to change how you behave on an ordinary Tuesday.

Core · Book

Meditations

Marcus Aurelius

A Roman emperor's private notes to himself, never meant for publication. The most personal document in ancient philosophy.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoHow To Read Marcus Aurelius' MeditationsDaily Stoic

On how to approach a book that has no argument structure and was not written for you.

Open companion
Core · Book

Discourses and Selected Writings

Epictetus

Epictetus was born a slave. His distinction between what is up to you and what is not is the hardest idea in Stoicism to actually apply.

Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Discourses of EpictetusEudaimonia

An animated walk through the core of the Discourses.

Open companion
Core · Book

Letters from a Stoic

Seneca

Letters to a friend on grief, money, crowds and dying. Seneca was fabulously rich and advising on poverty, which is worth holding in mind as you read.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoSeneca: Letters from a StoicEudaimonia

The main themes of the letters, and the tension between Seneca's advice and his life.

Open companion
Module 5

Faith and Reason

For a thousand years the central question was whether reason and revelation could both be true. The answers built the vocabulary that later philosophy would use to attack religion.

Core · Book

Confessions

Augustine of Hippo

The first autobiography in the Western tradition, and an argument about time, memory and desire disguised as a life story.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
Video05. St. Augustine's ConfessionsYaleCourses

A full Yale lecture on what Augustine is doing beneath the confessional surface.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Consolation of Philosophy

Boethius

Written in prison while awaiting execution. Philosophy appears as a woman and argues him out of self-pity. The most read book in medieval Europe after the Bible.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoBoethius's Consolation of PhilosophyThe School of Life

The circumstances of the book, which are inseparable from its argument.

Open companion
Core · Book

Proslogion

Anselm of Canterbury

Contains the ontological argument, which tries to prove God exists from the definition of the word alone. Almost everyone thinks it fails and nobody agrees on why.

Companion · use alongside
VideoAnselm and the Argument for GodCrashCourse

The argument stated clearly, then the standard objections.

Open companion
Core · Book

Summa Theologiae: Selected Questions

Thomas Aquinas

Aquinas absorbs Aristotle into Christian theology, having received him through Arabic commentators. Read the Five Ways and the structure of the objections.

Companion · use alongside
VideoAquinas and the Cosmological ArgumentsCrashCourse

The Five Ways in ten minutes, with the objections Aquinas himself anticipated.

Open companion
Module 6

The Modern Self

Philosophy turns inward and asks what a single mind can know on its own. The question produces both the rationalist and empiricist traditions, and they end up in very different places.

Core · Book

Meditations on First Philosophy

Rene Descartes

Six days of systematic doubt, discarding everything that can possibly be doubted, to see what survives. What survives is the thinker doing the doubting.

Companion · use alongside
VideoRene Descartes: Meditation #1, The Method of DoubtJeffrey Kaplan

A slow walk through the first Meditation, which is where the whole thing is set up.

Open companion
Core · Book

Observations upon Experimental Philosophy

Margaret Cavendish

Cavendish argued against Descartes and Hobbes in print in the 1660s, when no woman was admitted to the Royal Society whose experiments she was criticising.

Companion · use alongside
VideoScience, Materialism, Minds and God: Margaret CavendishPhilosophy Tube

Her materialism, and why she was written out of the story for three centuries.

Open companion
Core · Book

An Essay Concerning Human Understanding

John Locke

The mind as a blank sheet written on by experience. Long, so read the first two books and the chapter on personal identity.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoLocke, Berkeley and EmpiricismCrashCourse

Where Locke sits between Descartes and Hume, and what Berkeley did to him.

Open companion
Core · Book

An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding

David Hume

Hume points out that no amount of past evidence justifies a claim about the future, and no philosopher has fully answered him since.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
Video3.3 The Problem of InductionUniversity of Oxford

An Oxford lecture on the argument that broke empiricism from the inside.

Open companion
Module 7

Kant and Wollstonecraft

Kant tries to rescue knowledge from Hume by arguing that the mind supplies the structure of experience. Wollstonecraft applies Enlightenment reasoning to the half of humanity the Enlightenment ignored.

Core · Book

Prolegomena to Any Future Metaphysics

Immanuel Kant

Kant's own attempt to make the Critique of Pure Reason readable. Start here, not with the Critique.

Companion · use alongside
VideoBeginner's Guide to Kant's Metaphysics and EpistemologyPhilosophy Tube

Six minutes on the single idea that makes Kant make sense.

Open companion
Core · Book

Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals

Immanuel Kant

Morality derived from reason alone, with no appeal to consequences, God or feeling. The most demanding ethical theory anyone has proposed.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoImmanuel Kant's Moral TheoryJeffrey Kaplan

The categorical imperative worked through with examples, including where it appears to give the wrong answer.

Open companion
Core · Book

A Vindication of the Rights of Woman

Mary Wollstonecraft

Written in six weeks in 1792. Wollstonecraft accepts the Enlightenment premise that reason makes us human and asks why nobody applied it to women.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoMary Wollstonecraft: A Vindication of the Rights of WomanJames Muldoon

The argument and the political moment it was written into.

Open companion
Module 8

The Nineteenth Century

Three attacks on the confident rational self: from utility, from faith, and from suspicion. After this century philosophy stops assuming that reason is in charge.

Core · Book

Utilitarianism

John Stuart Mill

The greatest happiness of the greatest number, defended by someone who saw the obvious objections coming. Short and unusually honest about the difficulties.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoUtilitarianismJeffrey Kaplan

The theory, the standard counterexamples, and Mill's attempts to survive them.

Open companion
Core · Book

Fear and Trembling

Soren Kierkegaard

Abraham is told to kill his son. Kierkegaard argues that if faith is real then ethics cannot be the highest thing, which is a genuinely disturbing conclusion.

Companion · use alongside
VideoFear and Trembling: Kierkegaard on Faith and AnxietyEternalised

The knight of faith, and why Kierkegaard thought Hegel had missed the point entirely.

Open companion
Core · Book

On the Genealogy of Morals

Friedrich Nietzsche

Nietzsche asks where our moral feelings came from historically, and answers that they were invented by the weak. Whether or not he is right, the question was new.

Companion · use alongside
VideoNietzsche's Genealogy of MoralsJeffrey Kaplan

Master and slave morality set out plainly, without the mythology that usually surrounds Nietzsche.

Open companion
Module 9

Existence and Freedom

If there is no given human nature and no external meaning, everything is your responsibility. Three writers who took that seriously, and one who showed the men had not noticed half the problem.

Core · Book

The Second Sex

Simone de Beauvoir

One is not born a woman, one becomes one. Nine hundred pages of philosophy, history and interview material that founded modern feminist theory.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoBeauvoir's Second Sex: IntroductionOverthink Podcast

Two academic philosophers on the introduction, which is where the argument is.

Open companion
Core · Book

Existentialism Is a Humanism

Jean-Paul Sartre

A public lecture defending existentialism against the charge that it is gloomy and irresponsible. The clearest short statement of the position.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoSartre, Existentialism is a HumanismOverthink Podcast

What Sartre means by existence preceding essence, and the objections he was answering.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Myth of Sisyphus

Albert Camus

Camus opens by saying the only serious philosophical problem is suicide, then spends the book arguing you should not.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoThe Philosophy of the Absurd: Camus's Myth of SisyphusEternalised

The absurd as Camus defines it, which is neither pessimism nor despair.

Open companion
Module 10

The Analytic Turn

A programme to make philosophy scientific, its demolition, and a man who decided the whole project was a misunderstanding of language. Read these three in this order and you have an argument, not a survey.

Core · Book

Language, Truth and Logic

A.J. Ayer

Ayer at twenty-six declares that any statement that cannot be verified is literally meaningless, which disposes of theology, ethics and most of metaphysics.

Companion · use alongside
VideoLogical Positivism, The Scientific Approach to PhilosophyPhilosophy Vibe

The verification principle stated clearly, before anyone starts attacking it.

Open companion
Core · Essay

Two Dogmas of Empiricism

W.V.O. Quine

Twenty pages published in 1951 that took apart the distinction Ayer's whole programme rested on. Arguably the most consequential philosophy paper of the century.

Companion · use alongside
VideoQuine: Two Dogmas of EmpiricismSimon Cushing

A full lecture on the paper. Dense, and the only way to see exactly where the knife goes in.

Open companion
Core · Book

Philosophical Investigations

Ludwig Wittgenstein

Wittgenstein rejects his own earlier work and argues that meaning is use, not reference. Written in numbered fragments, which is deliberate.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoWittgenstein's Language-games made easyPhilosophy Battle

Language games and the beetle in the box, explained at the pace the ideas actually need.

Open companion
Module 11

After the Canon

Three philosophers writing after 1945 who asked what the tradition had left out: politics as action, race as a philosophical problem, and attention as a moral act.

Core · Book

The Human Condition

Hannah Arendt

Arendt separates labour, work and action, and argues that modern life has quietly eliminated the third. A political philosophy built from a distinction nobody had drawn.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoHannah Arendt's Human ConditionStJohnsPipeCasts

From St John's College, whose entire degree is close reading of books like this one.

Open companion
Core · Book

Black Skin, White Masks

Frantz Fanon

A psychiatrist from Martinique on what colonialism does inside the mind of the colonised. Philosophy, clinical observation and autobiography at once.

Open the core text
Companion · use alongside
VideoFrantz Fanon, Black Skin, White MasksGregory B. Sadler

A philosopher working through the book chapter by chapter.

Open companion
Core · Book

The Sovereignty of Good

Iris Murdoch

Murdoch argues against the whole existentialist picture of morality as choice, and for morality as a matter of learning to see other people accurately.

Companion · use alongside
VideoIris Murdoch's Moral PhilosophyTimeline Theological Videos

A lecture by Cathy Mason on attention, which is Murdoch's central and least obvious idea.

Open companion
Module 12

Philosophy Now

Three living or recent philosophers writing for readers rather than colleagues, on consciousness, justice and what a good life requires.

Core · Book

What Does It All Mean?

Thomas Nagel

Ninety pages covering knowledge, mind, free will, death and meaning. Nagel refuses to simplify, and the book is still readable in an afternoon.

Companion · use alongside
VideoWhat is it Like to be a Bat?Jeffrey Kaplan

Nagel's most famous argument, on why consciousness resists scientific explanation.

Open companion
Core · Book

Creating Capabilities

Martha Nussbaum

An account of what a society owes people, framed as capabilities rather than resources or preferences. Developed with Amartya Sen and now used in real policy.

Companion · use alongside
VideoCreating Capabilities: Martha NussbaumHarvard University Press

Nussbaum setting out the approach in her own words.

Open companion
Core · Book

Justice

Michael J. Sandel

Sandel runs the major theories against hard cases: trolleys, conscription, surrogacy, price gouging. The book of the most watched university course in the world.

Companion · use alongside
VideoJustice: What's The Right Thing To Do? Episode 01Harvard University

The first lecture of the Harvard course, which is where the book came from.

Open companion